Wade Wilson’s Death-Row Case: What the Record Shows About the Prison Claims and His Florida Appeal
CAPE CORAL, Fla. — Wade Steven Wilson was sentenced to death in August 2024 for murdering Kristine Melton and Diane Ruiz, two Cape Coral women killed on the same day in October 2019. A Florida Supreme Court docket lists his mandatory appeal as open, and the court’s video archive records a brief hearing on February 5, 2026. The records reviewed for this article do not establish an execution date.
The headline’s account of Wilson being dragged to a cell after an outburst over “victim payouts” could not be verified. The court materials and reporting reviewed did not substantiate the claims of heavy sedation or suicide watch, identify correctional officers who described such an incident, or establish the existence of a tape recorded hours before the murders. There is a documented account of phone calls Wilson made on the day of the killings, along with a later jail call featured in a documentary. The timing matters.
What happened to Kristine Melton and Diane Ruiz
On October 7, 2019, Wilson killed Melton, 35, in her Cape Coral home. According to the state attorney’s office, he strangled her while she was asleep and took her car. He then drove to a business in Fort Myers, where he attacked his girlfriend. She got away and contacted law enforcement. Later that day, Wilson approached Ruiz, 43, while she was walking in Cape Coral. Prosecutors said he asked for directions to get her into the car, then assaulted and killed her.
A Lee County jury found Wilson guilty of both first-degree murders on June 12, 2024. The jury also convicted him of offenses including motor vehicle theft, battery and burglary. The case then moved to a separate penalty phase, during which jurors heard evidence about the crimes, testimony about Wilson’s background and statements from the victims’ relatives before recommending a sentence for each murder.
Ruiz’s son, Zane Romero, and a cousin of Melton spoke about the effect of the killings on their families. After sentencing, Ruiz’s father spoke publicly about losing his daughter. Melton’s cousin described the nearly five years the family had spent waiting for the case to reach that point. Their testimony and public remarks documented the consequences of the murders for the people who knew the two women.
The phone calls and the claimed tape
Wilson’s biological father, Steven Testasecca, testified in June 2024 that Wilson called him several times on the day of the murders. Testasecca said he initially doubted what he was hearing. During a later call that evening, Wilson gave details that made him take the account seriously. Information from the conversation was relayed to police, who arrested Wilson the following day. The calls Testasecca described concerned killings that had already happened.
There is also a later call with a clear date. People reported that documentary footage included a conversation between Wilson and Testasecca from the Lee County Jail on October 10, 2019, while authorities were still looking for Ruiz. That places the jail call three days after the murders. Neither the father’s testimony about the October 7 calls nor the reporting on the October 10 jail call corroborates the claim of a recording made hours before the killings.
What the record says about payments and custody
The public sentencing coverage describes victim-impact testimony, during which relatives explained how the murders had affected them. Florida also operates a separate crime-victim compensation program that can help eligible applicants with expenses such as funeral costs, lost income or counseling. The existence of that program does not establish that either family received a particular payment, or that Wilson learned of one and reacted to it in custody.
Local reporting did identify a financial penalty in a separate proceeding. Days after Wilson received the death sentences, he pleaded no contest in other pending cases and was ordered to pay a $50,000 state fine, along with costs and another fee. The report identifies the $50,000 as a fine payable to the state. It provides no support for the claimed payments to the families or for the alleged confrontation with prison guards.
The penalty phase also included competing expert testimony about Wilson’s mental and neurological condition. A defense neurologist said testing and imaging suggested possible brain damage. A medical examiner testifying for the state disagreed with his interpretation of the scans. Those were opinions presented during sentencing. They do not verify the separate claims about medication, suicide watch or how prison staff handled Wilson after the hearing.
Why the appeal turns on the jury votes
The jury recommended death by 9–3 for Melton’s murder and 10–2 for Ruiz’s murder. Judge Nick Thompson imposed both death sentences on August 27, 2024. Under Florida’s 2023 sentencing law, at least eight jurors must support a death recommendation. The law separately requires a unanimous finding of at least one aggravating factor before a defendant is eligible for a death sentence. The distinction matters because neither of Wilson’s sentencing recommendations was unanimous.
Wilson’s appellate lawyer, Michael Ufferman, argued that applying the newer voting threshold to crimes committed in 2019 was impermissibly retroactive. At the February hearing, he acknowledged that the Florida Supreme Court had already rejected comparable arguments in Hunt v. State. Rather than repeat his written arguments, he said he intended to preserve them for possible review by the U.S. Supreme Court. Florida’s lawyer asked the justices to affirm the lower court. The transcript ends with the justices thanking counsel. It records no decision announced from the bench that morning.
The public docket reviewed for this article lists Wilson’s direct appeal as open. His lawyer’s stated intention to seek federal review does not establish that the U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to hear the case. The two death sentences are the result of the 2024 judgment. The February hearing was part of the review of that judgment, and the available records do not show a signed execution warrant for Wilson.